• Failed planning
    August 11,2014

    Failed planning

    Marc Brown asks, in effect, “What were they thinking?” when New England’s state energy planners backed building 25-cent-per-kilowatt-hour wind projects while opposing reliable, existing, low-cost generators like Vermont Yankee nuclear power plant.

    They were thinking New England would have endless amounts of “fracked” natural gas; they were wrong. Contrary to “expert” predictions of just a few years ago, demand has outstripped deliverable supply causing prices to climb steadily and spike drastically when the weather is at its hottest and coldest.

    They were thinking New England could always buy more Canadian hydropower; they were wrong. As with natural gas, there’s not enough transmission capacity. Efforts to build new power lines have yielded controversy, spending, but no new cross-border transmission.

    And finally, they were thinking that closing a big, base load nuclear power plant or two would push New England utilities into the waiting arms of intermittent solar and wind power; they were wrong. You cannot replace base load power sources with intermittent ones, so electric utilities were instead forced into the waiting arms of high carbon fossil fuel.

    In short, they thought their foresight and strong-arm regulatory tactics would bend the region’s energy market to their will. The market is bent, but instead of the result they wanted, they got the worst case scenario: higher emissions and higher prices.

    George Coppenrath


    MORE IN Letters
    What is wrong with the world today was summed up on a BBC News page Oct. Full Story
    Nobody can defend Trump’s words on the tape, and we shouldn’t defend Clinton’s lies and... Full Story
    I’d like to comment on your editorial of Oct. 6 entitled “Unfunny joke. Full Story
    More Articles
    • VIDEOS
    • PHOTOS