• Dark side of victory
    June 06,2014
     

    On the morning of June 7, 1944, the excitement among my classmates at my school in Dundee, Scotland, was inescapable. My fellow 10-year-olds were all talking and laughing about the huge invasion of the day before, the day that forever since has been known as D-Day.

    I didnít join in the celebration, and a friend wondered why.

    ďLots of lives are being lost in that invasion,Ē I remarked, glumly.

    It wasnít that I didnít welcome the long-anticipated invasion. The war, after all, had dominated our lives since September 1939 and we were tired of air raid shelters and gas masks and all the other intrusive appurtenances of war.

    No, my glum attitude that otherwise happy morning arose from the fact that my mother had patiently explained to me over breakfast that there is always ó and she stressed the ďalwaysĒ ó a dark side to such military missions.

    My mother had reason to be especially conscious of that dark side.

    By June 1944, my brother, Richard, had been a prisoner of the Germans for two years ó he would not make it home ó and my father was the skipper of an American Liberty ship and had been lucky to survive the deadly North Atlantic convoys and especially the always-risky convoys to Murmansk in the north of the Soviet Union.

    With my father gone, my mother ran our family business, Scotlandís first American-style gas station, but of course the war meant there were few customers. In fact, I can remember only two trips I ever took in private vehicles during the war years.

    A neighbor, a traveling salesman who took me with him one day, believing I needed something to lift my spirits, owned one of them; the other belonged to an uncle who had an important government job. I remember he would shift into neutral going downhill, hoping that doing so would save fuel.

    Somehow the gas station survived the rationing and the absence of private cars (it had a scale that brought in money from trucks that needed to be weighed, and there were military vehicles that needed fuel), and it certainly kept my motherís attention on the job and less on her worries about her husband and her son.

    But back to D-Day: Keep in mind that in April and May, just in the preparations for the invasion, Allied air forces lost nearly 12,000 men and more than 2,000 aircraft.

    The National D-Day Memorial Foundation, an American organization, has carefully recorded the names of 2,499 American D-Day fatalities and 1,915 from the other Allied nations. The total ó 4,414 ó far exceeds the level that previously was generally accepted, 2,500.

    So, my motherís attitude on the morning after the invasion was justified. Yet it also served to deprive me of a chance to join in the elation that dominated my school day. I remember feeling almost estranged from all my friends. But I have no other memories of that day.

    Years later, though, I would befriend two people who actually participated in Operation Overlord, as D-Day was called by its military masters. One of them is Bob Davis, of Plainfield, who parachuted into Normandy, and the other is Morley Piper, of Essex, Massachusetts, the longtime executive director of what then was called The New England Newspaper Association. He waded ashore as a second lieutenant.

    Iím in awe of these two friends. Iíve never served in the military (as a sole surviving son, I was turned away when I tried to enlist during the Korean War), and my only exposure to the hazards of war came during the early days of World War II when the Germans bombed Dundee several times.

    Bob Davis and Morley Piper came home safely from the war and went about their business. They were both successful in their civilian lives. And Iím extremely proud to call them my friends.

    But my mind still reels at the loss of life that happened as a result of the D-Day invasion. Letís celebrate the 70th anniversary of the event that proved to be the beginning of the end for Hitler and so many others of his ilk.

    Letís think about them, too. My mother certainly did.



    Alexander Hutchison is a former editor of The Times Argus.

    MORE IN Commentary
    The Tenement Museum, on the Lower East Side of Manhattan, is one of my favorite places in New... Full Story
    It is a common custom to offer a tip for the 5 or 10 minutes of time that your waitress spends... Full Story
    Two of the greatest pieces of prose in English were written by the same person less than 16... Full Story
    More Articles
  •  
     
    • MEDIA GALLERY 
    • VIDEOS
    • PHOTOS