Editions: e-Edition | Lite | Mobile | Subscribe | Twitter | RSS
Manage: My Account | Logout

TimesArgus.com - We Are Vermont

Cooperation would work



Toolbox

Published: October 26, 2009

At the Vermont Farmers' Forum for Dairy Farm Survival (Oct. 16), expert panelists explained that dairying would be profitable now if all dairy farmers cut their milk production by as little as three percent, whether by feeding their cows a bit less or culling a few, either of which would reduce their costs, adding to their profits as the price of raw milk rose.

They also explained that dairy farms' profitability or unprofitability has little or no connection to prices of dairy products, because wholesalers and retailers control these.

Winner of the 2009 Nobel Prize for Economics Prof. Elinor Ostrow's work has demonstrated that cooperation prevents the "tragedy of the commons," where none benefits because all competed to maximize theirs.

What if all dairy farmers agreed to cut their production by such a small amount, and were not paid for any excess?

"With public sentiment, nothing can fail; without it, nothing can succeed." (Abraham Lincoln, first debate with Stephen A. Douglas, 1858).

Howard Fairman

Vernon



Follow us on Facebook and Twitter.





READER COMMENTS


Farmers used to enjoy price supports..however, the concept of selling at a fixed price no matter the quality wasn't lost on them. They made as much as thy could, resulting in the government buying the unsold extra and storing it in non-fat dry milk, butter and cheese. The costs of storage were in ADDITION to the cost of the supports. It was a money pit as manufacturers also made sure they didn't lose profit by keeping prices high and demand under control..
If only there were controlled prices AND production quotas..
-- Posted by CJ maloney on Mon, Oct 26, 2009, 12:22 pm EST

report this comment



What, if Farmers get paid more than "minimum" wage? The retailers, and processors, wholesalers, etc say if farmers need more money then the Gov't should up minimum price per hundred weight. Then farmers wouldn't need to produce as much. Hell they probably wouldn't have to work as much and have more time for family and friends.

Douglas Duprey
Marshfield, VT
-- Posted by Douglas Duprey on Mon, Oct 26, 2009, 9:55 am EST

report this comment



The idea of quotas is nothing new...look to our neighbors to the north for a great example. In fact, the quotas issued can be sold among farmers, as some retire.
-- Posted by CJ maloney on Mon, Oct 26, 2009, 6:38 am EST

report this comment


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Logout