TimesArgus.com - We Are Vermont

Barre manager sees bump in salary, perks



John C. Craig

Toolbox

By David Delcore TIMES ARGUS STAFF - Published: July 28, 2009

BARRE – City Manager John Craig is getting a healthy bump in his annual salary, evidence that city councilors are pleased with the performance of their chief administrator.

Although councilors are expected to conclude Craig's annual evaluation during an executive session tonight, they have already ratified a contract that reflects a first-year pay raise of 10 percent. Based on that contract, Craig's annual salary will immediately climb from the roughly $77,500 he was paid during the recently concluded fiscal year to $85,218.

Mayor Thomas Lauzon said that is in keeping with a performance-related discussion the council had with Craig before he was hired two years ago. At the time, Lauzon said, Craig asked to be paid more than the $75,000 the city was offering, but was told he'd have to earn it on the job.

Lauzon said Craig has – living up to the potential the council saw in him when they offered him a two-year contract in July 2007 and earning the right to be paid salary comparable to those who manage similarly sized Vermont communities.

"I think we're getting a bargain, I really do," he said, stressing the council was well aware the salary they offered Craig was at the low end of the pay range for municipal managers according to data compiled by the Vermont League of Cities and Towns.

Although Craig came to the job with an impressive resume, Lauzon said the fact he had no hands-on experience in municipal management at the time prompted the council to offer a somewhat less competitive compensation package with the understanding the issue would be revisited when his contract expired.

"We're living up to a commitment that we made to John (Craig) two years ago," he said.

Under the terms of the new agreement, Craig's salary will be adjusted in the contract's second and third years at least by the average of the annual across-the-board pay raises afforded other city employees. The contract gives the council the opportunity to further compensate Craig based on the results of his annual performance evaluations by giving him an additional pay raise, a bonus, or both.

There are a host of other minor adjustments to an employment agreement that runs through June 30, 2012.

The contract grants Craig a fourth week of vacation in addition to one week of bankable sick leave, increases his allowance for professional development from $2,000 to $2,200, and adjusts the compensation he will receive for the use of his car and his cell phone.

During his first year on the job Craig received an $1,800 allowance for the use of his car. That figure increased by 4 percent last year. Under his new contract he will be paid $2,200 this year, and the allowance will increase by 5 percent in the second and third year of the contract.

The council agreed to the same annual 5 percent escalator for calculating Craig's professional development allowance.

Under his old contract the city agreed to furnish Craig with a cell phone. The new agreement requires the city to pay him $100 a month for the use of his personal cell phone.

The city will continue to pay for 80 percent of the cost of Craig's health and dental insurance premiums over the life of the contract and will cover the cost of a $225,000 life insurance policy for the manager.

In the event the council chooses not to renew the contract or terminates Craig without just cause, he will be entitled to a lump sum payment equal to 18 weeks pay in addition to pay for accrued vacation, and other benefits.








READER COMMENTS


burl doesn't have a CM - they have a full time mayor. he made 88,612 last yr. here's a few of the other salaries for LAST YEAR in burlington...

chief admin officer - 81,085
city attorney - 93,935
director planning - 71,601
fire chief - 90,067
police chief - 93,826
parks director - 75,009
director public works - 85,280
total salaries - 18,537,461

http://www.ci.burlington.vt.us/ct/budget/2009/FY09BudgetSection7.pdf

you people need to get over it. this is what smart, educated, professional managers make. anyone ever spoken with him about running the city or offered any ideas? ever consider what hes working with?
-- Posted by Anon ymous on Thu, Jul 30, 2009, 10:48 pm EST

report this comment



-- Posted by Tam Suleman on Thu, Jul 30, 2009, 7:19 am EST

Thanks for the refresher in statistics.

Nevertheless,

even if it's median income and not average income
comparing the 'median' income for Barre and Burlington is comparing apples to apples.

But the unanswered question is: How much does the Burlington City Manager make?
Then we would have an idea if Barre's City Managers salary is a fair compensation.

.
-- Posted by A None on Thu, Jul 30, 2009, 6:27 pm EST

report this comment



I hope you didn't fall asleep during those statistics courses in school. The numbers listed on Joe Fridays link provided the median income and not the "average". That means that 50% make more than 35985 and 50% make less. It also takes into account part time work.
-- Posted by Tam Suleman on Thu, Jul 30, 2009, 7:19 am EST

report this comment



Average Joe
-- Posted by Joe Friday on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 2:19 pm EST

Thanks for that info.
The odd thing is that you can't find any info on that site about Barre Town.

According to that site the average household income is $36,000 for Barre compared to an average income of $50,000 for all of Vermont.

The average household income for Burlington is $40,000.
I wonder how much the the Burlington city manager makes.
-- Posted by A None on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 7:11 pm EST

report this comment



See article:
Barre police log: July 22 - 27
-- Posted by Betty 2 Cents on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 2:47 pm EST

report this comment



This guy ought to be ashamed of himself. Most of the families in this area that work hard, participate in the community, volunteer for services do not make this as a combined family income. Plus he dosen't have expenses to pay with this income to boot. I wish that I had just on of those perks, then again I live just fine without them. Maybe, he will personally fix the pot holes in the road in front of my house. That would be a nice perk for me. Or make it so I can go eat dinner and have a creamy in my own community without feeling the dread dealing with the sad scene downtown.
-- Posted by Betty 2 Cents on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 2:42 pm EST

report this comment



For statistics on Barre City go here:

http://www.city-data.com/city/Barre-Vermont.html

Heck, $50,000 would be a lot for many people in Barre!

Watch for the rain folks! It's coming soon!

Average Joe
-- Posted by Joe Friday on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 2:19 pm EST

report this comment



Look it ain't hard to aquire a marketable skill. Obviously if an idiot reads a book, probably isnt going to do much good. However once you learn that reading is the best source of information. Than life will be alot easier for you. There aren't many self made people around here, who worked for every penny they have.

Unfortunely for the rest of you OK THEN does $90k or better per year, and its not all its cracked up to be.
-- Posted by ok then on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 2:04 pm EST

report this comment



ok then - I think you need to do more than just read a book to acquire a skill and obtain a job in that particular field. Personally speaking, I'd never hire a contractor who just decided he wanted to do carpentry work so he read a book.
-- Posted by Mel Parker on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 12:47 pm EST

report this comment



Keep in mind; He is our city manager, not our Walmart manager.
You often get what you pay for.
You need to compare his salary to other CM's salaries not to what a cashier at Dollar General makes.
You cannot complain about how run down and junky Barre is AND refuse to pay good money to get the right people in to help change it.
Lastly, a contract is a contract. Good times or bad.
-- Posted by Jim Richards on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 9:46 am EST

report this comment



Hey go look at the Montpelier adn Barre police logs posted. By the looks of it, there is virtually nothing happening nad it would seem there are too many police officers in both towns.
They may post DUI once in a while other than that it a DUI is the top news story, then the logs show the rest of the occurances, then City manager probably doesnt have a whole lot to manage and there are too many police for the number of so-called crimes.
-- Posted by Are you Kidding? on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 9:08 am EST

report this comment



OK Then - $85K is a lot for an individual. After taxes and benefitd he gets about $1200 a week.

A None - You can get that info from the State of Vermont Tax Dept's website. Just don't use apostrophe's as it might have been programmed by OK Then.

Enjoy the weather before it rains all!

Average Joe
-- Posted by Joe Friday on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 8:03 am EST

report this comment



Very, very well stated Tam!
-- Posted by Greg Guyette on Wed, Jul 29, 2009, 7:36 am EST

report this comment



Ever heard of aquiring a marketable skill and selling it.

If I wanted to be a lawyer I would read law books. If I wanted to be a carpenter I would read up on carpentry. If I wanted to be an line worker I would read up on electrical work.

Once people realize that the only people companies typically hire are those who are skilled in what they are doing, if will be a whole lot easier. If you know that companies in Barre are looking for guys who are skilled carpenters regularly for decent pay. Why not try reading books on carpentry every night. That way when you go to the job interviews you can say "Hey I know more than the last 20 guys that just came in here and said they can do anything." Nobody cares if you can do anything. I bet if you told them that you spent the last year reading books learning about the type of business they are in, you would be more marketable than someone who walks into a place an says "I can do anything."

I know this may seem like useless advice that you have heard a million times. Mabe one of these times you will actually try it, than you will figure out what it means to make money at something your good at. It doesnt nessarily mean that you will enjoy doing it. Doesn't matter as long as you can do what ever it is you do and do it good.
-- Posted by ok then on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 11:38 pm EST

report this comment



"A none: If you are un happy with the jobs that are available to you in central Vermont than create your own. There's plenty of money out there if you know how to make it."

Thanks for the advice ok then.

I'm not unhappy.

But maybe I'm not aware of how much money is out there and how to get a hold of it.
Any suggestions?
-- Posted by A None on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 10:37 pm EST

report this comment



A none: If you are un happy with the jobs that are available to you in central Vermont than create your own. There's plenty of money out there if you know how to make it.

A P: If you managed to do all that on $40k combined salaries your a better budgeter than me. Unfortunely this is 2009, I promise you that if you made $85k per year, you'd wish you were making more.
-- Posted by ok then on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 10:29 pm EST

report this comment



"You have given up and have gladly accepted the meager wages that our corporate benefactors have set for us."

It's not a matter of having giving up.

It's a matter of choice.

If you want to live here
you take any job that makes it possible.

And that is the problem.
How many jobs are here in Vermont that make it possible to live here?
.
-- Posted by A None on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 10:21 pm EST

report this comment



Sorry!! That last comment should have been addressed to "ok then"! My apologies to A None!
-- Posted by A P on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 9:06 pm EST

No offense taken.
Thank you for your correction.

Now,
in regards to the City Manager
can anybody actually point out what specifically he did to improve the life of the average Barre citizen that they would be okay with him making that kind of money?
-- Posted by A None on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 10:13 pm EST

report this comment



It seems that you people who complain about excessive wages for upper middle class managers have been brought up with a mindset that has sold yourselves short long ago. You have given up and have gladly accepted the meager wages that our corporate benefactors have set for us. Don't you think you deserve more instead of wishing that others earn less?
-- Posted by Tam Suleman on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 10:10 pm EST

report this comment



This is what I like to know:

What is the average income of Barre City citizens and the average income of Barre Town residents?

And
how much property do Barre Town residents own in Barre City?

Basically
who owns Barre City?

.
According to the reenacted fist fight between the city and town
history has been reversed.
Lauzon got hurt and admitted that he lost.

Now,
is that the level of politics in Barre?

.
-- Posted by A None on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 9:57 pm EST

report this comment



If this guy is getting paid $85k a year from the city of Barre, than he is prolly worth a few million a year to them. There probably aren't many people who reside in Barre City who make much more than $30k per year. Considering most property owners and business owners in Barre, don't actually live in Barre City.
Is 85k Alot of money for someone in Barre City? YES. Is 85k alot of money for an educated person who is good at what they do? NO. Like I said before after state and federal taxes 85k is only about 50k. Than hopefully the money that you save all year is enough to pay off whatever you owe at the end of the year.
-- Posted by ok then on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 9:12 pm EST

report this comment



Sorry!! That last comment should have been addressed to "ok then"! My apologies to A None!
-- Posted by A P on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 9:06 pm EST

report this comment



A None,
What planet do you live on? When we were starting out my ex-husband and I made less than half of that salary with our combined full time incomes. We had a car payment, mortgage, two kids, two dogs and managed without public assistance. In fact, we still managed to take a modest vacation, but certainly not 4 weeks worth! We also survived without professional development compensation, although it would have helped a great deal. Now I am managing on my own with even less and still able to provide for myself and my family. We live in Vermont, not New York City. Materialism is not all it is cracked up to be.
-- Posted by A P on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 9:04 pm EST

report this comment



"Unfortunely $85k isnt really a whole lot of money."

What I would like to know
what is the percentage of Barre City residents that make less than that?
-- Posted by A None on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 8:52 pm EST

report this comment



Unfortunely $85k isnt really a whole lot of money. After taxes he probably only gets a $1,000 check each week. Which if you have a home a vehicle and a kid or two, really isnt enough but to barely get by on a modest mortgage and a decent car.
Someone would have to pay me a whole lot more than that, to go reappraise everyone in towns property. I guess it would be alot of money for someone who had none.
You'd have to pay me upwards of 150k in order for me to be responsible for barre city.
-- Posted by ok then on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 8:01 pm EST

report this comment



I'm happy to see that the recession is over in Barre City!! Must be taxes will go down next year and they'll finally fix the fence at Mathewson School playground and reinstall the light pole that has been down on the beltline since the winter. Now I can't wait to get my new tax bill!

Now I understand why he hasn't returned my email or my wife's phone call, he's busy riding around in his car talking on the cell phone. I think if he's being reimbursed for his cell phone then his number should be available to all city residents.
-- Posted by Darin on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 7:57 pm EST

report this comment



$100 a month for use of his "personal" cell phone? Does he have to make overseas calls or something? He's the city manager for all that's holy!! It's not like he takes off after criminals when the big CM appears in the sky. Yes, please - raise our taxes so that "what's for dinner?" call can be made. Boy, I'd manage a whole bunch of things if someone would pay my car and phone payments.
-- Posted by Pandora box on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 7:38 pm EST

report this comment



Can I be the Barre City Manager? Throw in some hotdogs with onions and I'm on board! WOW is all I can say...What does he do worth THAT kind of money?
-- Posted by Mel on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 1:20 pm EST

report this comment



Did the commenters only read the headline and not the article? This was a deal made with Mr Craig, that he accept a lower salary at first, then after proving his worth, get the normal salary for those in this position. Geez, he earned it, people. More reasonable to realize Barre got a bargain for 2 years!
-- Posted by None None on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 12:31 pm EST

report this comment



Why should Mr. Craig get a raise! Yes he might be doing a good job, at least someone thinks he is. However didn't Barre just laid people off earlier in the year because of BUDGET CUTS? So with the econmy the way it is why should he be getting that much of a raise if any at all??
Something certainley isn't right with people losing jobs and top management getting raises!!
-- Posted by Cally None on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 12:01 pm EST

report this comment



What is his car perk? an old Barre City police cruiser with 200,000 miles on it? Lets give more perks and less money like a ping pong table and an apartment free of charge at Downtown Rentals.
-- Posted by John Lamson on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 11:15 am EST

report this comment



As a Barre City tax payer, and as tough as the economy is at this time, I think this is the most disgusting thing ever. $77k salary in the state of VT, is what the average two person income alone is. Barre has deteriorated in every way possible, the city is filled with losers, whether they are hanging out on the streets or city offices. No city employee in such tough times deserves a salary increase, at any level!!!!
-- Posted by David None on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 10:57 am EST

report this comment



You mean, he asked for 150,000 dollars and took 77K? Ahhh ??
-- Posted by Joshua Bernstein on Tue, Jul 28, 2009, 10:17 am EST

report this comment


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Logout