TimesArgus.com - We Are Vermont

Teen killed, four hurt in Plainfield crash



Former schoolmates of Twinfield Union School graduate Caidin McKeever visit the site Tuesday on Route 2 in Plainfield village where McKeever was killed at about 2 a.m. when the car he was driving hit the scarred tree in the middle background. Four passengers in the car were injured.

STEFAN HARD/TIMES ARGUS

Toolbox

By Thatcher Moats Times Argus Staff - Published: June 24, 2009

PLAINFIELD – Dru-Ellen Riggs was at home in Plainfield village early Tuesday morning when she heard the sound of screeching tires followed by a tremendous crash that shook the house.

Riggs ran outside and saw that a car had veered off the road into a cluster of trees on the south side of Route 2 on the western end of the village.

"I saw the taillights over the hill, and knowing what they were likely to run into, I just called 9-1-1," said the 46-year-old Riggs.

The one-car accident killed Caidin McKeever, a 17-year-old who graduated Saturday from Twinfield Union School.

McKeever was driving the 2000 Honda Civic that hit the tree, and he died at the scene, according to the state police.

The four passengers were injured and taken to two different hospitals.

Elijah Mayhew, 17, was airlifted to Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center in New Hampshire with multiple chest fractures, police said. A hospital spokesperson said Mayhew, an East Calais resident, was in fair condition Tuesday afternoon.

The three other passengers were taken to Central Vermont Medical Center in Berlin.

Kerry Monahan, 21, of Plainfield, was admitted with severe facial cuts, police said. A nurse supervisor at the hospital said Monahan was in good condition.

Adam Sainz, 21, and Stephanie Scelz, 19, suffered minor cuts and bruising and were later released from the hospital, police said. Sainz lives in East Calais, and Scelz lives in Virginia, according to police.

No one in the car was wearing a seatbelt, police said, and they believe speed and alcohol may have contributed to the crash, which took place at about 2 a.m.

Police said they found bottles and cans of beer at the scene — part of the reason they believe alcohol may have been involved.

"That's part of it, but we don't just base it off that," said state police Sgt. Robert Danaher, who was the supervisor at the scene. "We have some other information that leads us to believe that the operator possibly had been drinking prior to the crash, but we won't know how much until we get the results of the toxicology report back."

Danaher said he could have those results within a week.

The amount of damage to the car led Danaher to believe speed may have played a role in the crash.

"The damage to the vehicle was extensive," he said.

Police are piecing together where the occupants of the car were in the 24 hours before the accident, which is standard when there is a fatal accident, said Danaher.

As of now it's unclear exactly where the occupants were and what they were doing before the crash, he said.

"We know at one point they were at the Plainfield rec field," he said. "We're not certain if they were coming from there when the crash occurred, but at some point during the evening they were there."

The investigation will continue, said Danaher.

McKeever was one of 34 members of Twinfield's class of 2009 and attended the school from elementary through high school, said Twinfield Principal Owen Bradley.

Monahan and Sainz were also Twinfield alumni, Bradley said.

McKeever, whom police listed as a Montpelier resident, was a "sweet, fun-loving kid" who enjoyed mountain biking, Bradley said.

"It's very sad, brutally sad," he added.

Bradley said McKeever's friends and members of the Twinfield community were gathering Tuesday to mourn the 17-year-old.

"The students and his friends are visiting with his family now, and they are all just trying to figure their way through this," Bradley said. "We're all just devastated and very sad."








READER COMMENTS


that's just crazy, because some people don't like someone elses opinion, nobody should be able to post. Come on people, last I knew it was a free country and free speech. I say if you don't like the comments then don't read them. Pretty plain and simple don't you think? If everyone agreed with everyone then we'd all be programmed robots. I don't believe most people post here to be mean and insensitive, it's only their opinion. This accident is very tragic, whether speed or alcohol was a factor or not. This is a time people need to pray for the victims and their families. We all did stupid stuff when we were younger, that's life, it's part of growing up. Some people take bigger risks than others and some have less experience than others. That doesn't make them bad people at all. They are human and tragedies happen everyday. We all need to learn from this terrible accident. My thoughts and prayers go out to Caiden's family and friends.

Emily
-- Posted by None None on Sun, Jun 28, 2009, 12:52 am EST

report this comment



http://www.timesargus.com/article/20090626/OPINION02/906260308/1022/OPINION02&frompost=1
-- Posted by Melissa B. on Fri, Jun 26, 2009, 12:13 pm EST

report this comment



There could be several reasons why this accident happened. It could be an accident. A 17 year old driver is not that experienced. Speed could be a factor. Alcohol could be a factor. Distraction by a car load of intoxicated people could be it. Maybe all of the above. Bottom line there is a good chance it could have been avoided. If one of the 21 year olds bought the booze and it is shown that the driver had alcohol in him then they should go to jail.
-- Posted by None None on Fri, Jun 26, 2009, 12:57 am EST

report this comment



This one is a good study oldeman.
http://www.udetc.org/documents/CompareDrinkRate.pdf
-- Posted by Melissa B. on Thu, Jun 25, 2009, 8:54 pm EST

report this comment



I found this Oldeman, not sure if there's an updated one, but maybe it will help you start researching.
http://www.druglibrary.org/schaffer/Misc/driving/s18p1.htm
-- Posted by Melissa B. on Thu, Jun 25, 2009, 8:49 pm EST

report this comment



I have a family member who lives in the vicinity of the accident. They heard what sounded like a car doing 90 miles per hr followed by a crashing sound. This is exactly why its important to do speed limits because the speed limit on that corner is only 35 miles per hr. I guess its no one's fault but its important that people know the dangers of driving at high speeds one error can cost you your life.
-- Posted by ok then on Thu, Jun 25, 2009, 7:05 pm EST

report this comment



Does anyone know if there are countries with much lower alcohol related driving deaths? Where is this NOT a problem? Is there such a place? If there is the US should study this.

.
-- Posted by Olde Man on Thu, Jun 25, 2009, 6:26 pm EST

report this comment



Post condolences here and nothing else.
-- Posted by None None on Thu, Jun 25, 2009, 8:19 am EST

report this comment



Two were 21 and two were 17.
-- Posted by student nurse on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 11:08 pm EST

report this comment



Thank you, Walt. That's exactly what people need to focus on.

Above all, we must always respect one another and see the world through others' eyes, not from our separate pedestals. Stop the preaching, please. My thoughts are with Caidin's friends and family.
-- Posted by rachel rudi on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 10:34 pm EST

report this comment



Everyone in the car was under 21 except for one person. I wonder if this person purchased the alcohol? I wonder if someone will be charged for providing the alcohol?
-- Posted by None None on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 7:07 pm EST

report this comment



Although everyone has the right to an opinion they are in no way entitled to having the Times Argus or anyone else provide a forum for their opinion. I've known Caidin since he was a toddler and I've been a friend and colleague of Mary McKeever for 16 years. Because I work at Twinfield I've tried desperately not to respond, but some of what I've read here these past two days defies common decency. Posting electronically and anonymously evidently provides people with illusions that what they have to say about a tragedy is more important than a family's comfort during the absolute worst days of their lives. Continually stating the painfully obvious is not helpful and is frequently revolting. The bare knuckle exchanges on this website regarding national and international issues are completely out of place when discussing the untimely death of a young man, a friend, a community member, a brother and a son. I would seriously hope that people would take a moment and ask themselves how they might feel in similar circumstances and subsequently realize that in situations such as this, silence is truly golden.
-- Posted by walt amses on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 6:10 pm EST

report this comment



Laurie, we can teach our children not to drink but are all of them really going to listen? Am I missing something? Does it say anywhere in the article that the parents gave their child permission to drink? I also am not a perfect parent and my children are not perfect but children learn by their mistakes. Lets hope that they also learn form their friends mistakes. God Bless the families going through such a tragedy.
-- Posted by None None on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 3:49 pm EST

report this comment



Not sure who removed my previous post but want it known that I am praying for the family but don't understand when teens and families will ever learn about alcohol and teen driving. You can hide under a brick and pray for the family every day but until we take a look at the problem this will continue to happen. The law is a 21 year old drinking age as far as I know at that is what I teach. We cannot continue to say let them drink they'll do it anyway. I'm not a perfect parent and I don't have a perfect teenager...although I think she's pretty good..but I'm going to do whatever I can to educate her and her friends about all of this.
-- Posted by Laurie Grimm on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 2:19 pm EST

report this comment



I posted a comment in regards to yesterdays article about parents needing to be parents, not friends and to be Pro-Active with their children, in no way was I trying to blame the parents of those kids of not being good parents. I appologize if it sounded that way, and I was surely not trying to represent my own kids as being perfect or myself being a perfect parent, my kids have made their mistakes as well as I. I have had to deal with the same issue the Student Nurse metioned, "I'll be at so and so's house for the night" when in fact my child was at a party instead, I found out when I received a call from a parent who went to this party to find their child, and spotted my child and gave me a call informing me my daughter was at this drinking party, which was 60 miles from where she was suppose to be. I did my best to restrain myself from going to this house, after talking with my wife we decided to confront my daughter the next morning about how her night went, and see what kind of story we would get, neither one of us slept very well and would have died if the phone had rang that night. As expected we got a BS story, and I could not restrain myself and spilled the beans that we new the truth, and consequences followed. I do practice being Pro-Active and if you are one of those parents that aren't and what I wrote offended you, then maybe it's time you woke up.
Sad to say, it is tragedy's such as this that make people take notice, such as myself. It shouldn't take a death of one of our kids to make us want to speak up.
Again my heart does go out to Caidin's family and the other families as well and I appologize if what I wrote was mis-interpreted by some of you readers. This whole event has been stressful on not only those families involved, but every family that has kids and that really care, real communities will always share each others pain during such a tragedy, their loss is our loss.
Any of you kids and young adults that read these comments should really take notice of how a bad decision can ruin not only your life, but how it can affect your entire community. Don't drink and Drive, better yet, Just Don't drink at all & please BUCKLE UP.

The Times Argus should never remove the Comment section, they should be thanked for having it available. Everyone is entitiled to their opinion, thats what makes America, America. If you take every comment or opinion made personally, and don't consider the source, maybe you should just avoid reading them altogether, who knows your opinion might be offensive to somebody as well! Thanks Times Argus!
-- Posted by David None on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 11:04 am EST

report this comment



My best wishes and heartfelt condolences go out to the families. Please do not be afraid to draw upon your community for help during difficult times. We're out here.
-- Posted by Bennett Shapiro on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 10:15 am EST

report this comment



I dont know how you people can blame the parents... If you knew Caidens parents you would know they did everything to keep there kids out of trouble. People should not blame the parents because every teen knows what can happen when they drink and drive. But i guess all you adults out there are thinking your kids are all perfect, well let me tell you what they arn't. Its really not hard to tell parents hey can i stay at this persons house and so on. So leave this poor family alone, you dont even know who they are so how can you judge. RIP Caiden. And let there be peace for Nick and Mary McKeever, i just hope they arn't seeing what people are posting on this page. I agree Times Argus should take these posted comments off. Thank god everyone else will be ok!!!
-- Posted by Twinfield Class of 2005 None on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 9:29 am EST

report this comment



I am praying for the family's. Timesargus , please remove the ability of people to post on this horrible tragedy!
-- Posted by miss kitty on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 9:08 am EST

report this comment



It is apparent that many of the parents on here posting think they are perfect parents. They obviously think that they always know where their teenager is at all times and know exactly what they are doing at all times. Well, here's a reality check. YOU PROBABLY DON'T! Teens know how to make up stories! It's not difficult for them to tell you they're going one place, when they're really going to a party. Or, even if they are in fact at the place they told you they were, they may tell you they're just hanging out playing video games, when in fact, there may be drinking involoved. So for all of you parents out there that think you're perfect and always know... you just may not always know. So STOP STOP STOP pointing fingers at these teen's poor parents!!! Just be thankful something like this didn't happen to your teen and family, and pray it never does. I pray it never does. My heart goes out to the families involoved in this nightmare and we can only hope that other teens and peers of these students will learn from this accident.

May you rest in peace Caidin. <3
-- Posted by student nurse on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 8:53 am EST

report this comment



Thanks Anonymous. This family has more than enough to deal with right now. I'm sorry for your loss.
-- Posted by None None on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 7:34 am EST

report this comment



leave this family alone
-- Posted by (Anonymous) on Wed, Jun 24, 2009, 6:34 am EST

report this comment


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Logout