TimesArgus.com - We Are Vermont

Restaurant seeks community support



Restaurant Phoebe owners Debbie and Aaron Millon sit at a window table in the Montpelier eatery.

STEFAN HARD/TIMES ARGUS

Toolbox

By SARAH HINCKLEY Times Argus Staff - Published: February 12, 2009

MONTPELIER – Before resorting to shuttering the door to Restaurant Phoebe, owners Aaron and Debbie Millon are reaching out for help from their community.

In this economic downturn, restaurants are struggling. Restaurant Phoebe, located on State Street in Montpelier, is no exception. But before throwing in the kitchen towel, the couple decided to ask friends, neighbors, patrons and foodies for financial assistance.

When chef and owner Aaron Millon sat down recently and realized he didn't have enough money to pay his 18 employees, he decided to write a letter asking for help.

"I will not let Restaurant Phoebe close unless somebody tells me it must, or I feel the quality of our ingredients must be compromised due to cost," he wrote in the letter that was sent to hundreds of people via email. "Despite this resolution, I would rather ask for the financial support from our community."

People who received the letter forwarded it on to others, and people from as far away as California responded. So far, although letters and calls of support have come back to the couple en mass, few people have made offers of financial support.

"We were looking at selling," said Debbie Millon, who also works as a director of the Bellwether School in Williston. "We're hitting the slow time now. Because of everything that happened, we don't really have the cash built up to move forward."

She admits a recent case of embezzlement by an employee, in which the restaurant lost about $2,000, was not a major catalyst to the crunch. It is as though the perfect storm has hit. Sales are decreasing because of the struggling economy and fewer people choosing to dine out. Local vendors and farmers, on which the restaurant relies to serve local and seasonal fare, are also struggling.

"They are tightening up themselves," said Debbie Millon, explaining that previously, payments could be made at the end of the week or once the product had been used. Now vendors need payment on delivery. "Both of those things are affecting our cash flow."

Restaurant Phoebe opened on Sept. 11, 2006 and seems to have hit hard times only recently.

"When we opened we were jammin'," said Aaron Millon, noting the business grew throughout 2007, but saw a decrease in 2008.

Sticking to a philosophy of slow food, local ingredients and supporting Vermont vendors is key to the business and not something the Millon's are looking to change.

"It's not just a burger," said Aaron Millon, about one of the lower cost items put on the menu. "The cows are five miles away. The people who grow and love those cows come in here to eat… It's what needs to happen if we want to keep ourselves on the planet."

Asking for community support has become another model of supporting businesses that is taking off in Vermont.

"It's a great way to bring capital to the business, as well as invest in the local economy," said Vicky Tebbetts, vice president of Vermont Hospitality Council, a division of the Vermont Chamber of Commerce. "Those who are being creative are those who realize they have to do something different."

There are 900 members of the state chamber, many of which are restaurants. Tebbetts said she has not heard of restaurants struggling and closing on a large scale in Vermont.

Others who have gone before the Millon's in asking their community for help, are realizing success from the venture.

"We have this built-in community of people who are financially invested in our success," said Sharon Deitz, owner of The Bee's Knees in Morrisville. "There's quite a number of community-supported enterprises in Vermont right now."

When the restaurant she owns took over her apartment in the same building, Deitz knew she needed to expand. She came up with a plan, with the help of the owners of Claire's in Hardwick, another community-share business, and put a letter in the restaurant requesting financial help.

Deitz was able to raise about $100,000 by offering $500 and $1,000 gift certificates in exchange for $90 of food per quarter for the next five years. People who were willing to loan the business $5,000 now get 10 percent off their purchases at the restaurant.

"It's not just borrowing money from the bank, it's this shared sense of accomplishment," said Deitz, who also had people contribute labor for the expansion in exchange for gift certificates to the restaurant. "It's spread out so we don't have a huge liability up front… We're still in the second month of this, so it's hard to say how it's really going to come out."

Deitz closed the doors to the restaurant for at least two weeks over the holidays to complete renovations and opened again after the start of the new year.

"Business has been great since we re-opened," said Deitz, noting sales in January are 70 percent over last year's sales at the same time. "Those are the signs that it's a good model to get people involved."

That is why the Millon's are looking to the community to be a part of their enduring success. Though they've yet to hammer out the details, Debbie was meeting with like-minded folk this week to figure out what kind of packages Restaurant Phoebe can offer the public.

"To have hit the economy when we did was such a crusher for us – but it forced us to tighten up our model," said Debbie Millon. "In some ways that was great, it forced us to line up our numbers."

For more information about how to get involved to support Restaurant Phoebe, contact them at dine@restaurantphoebe.com or call 262-3500.



Follow us on Facebook and Twitter.





READER COMMENTS


So let me see if I understand... they buy a restaurant then run it into the ground? Then they do it again? How? Where does the $$$ come from?

OK---forget that--- if there is something they do well there, it is on them to promote it to the public. That is what business is all about! Somebody just told me that their salmon is awesome... well, they should have a little table out front and hand out toothpicks full of salmon! DUH!

Too many restaurants around here operate on the principle that if everyone comes once then never comes back that they will do OK until they sell off. This works for a year or 2, and it sounds like Phoebe already knows all about it.
-- Posted by None None on Tue, Feb 17, 2009, 9:42 am EST

report this comment



If they close down before the end of the 5 years, do the people get their money back? Probably not.
-- Posted by Take back This City on Sun, Feb 15, 2009, 6:33 pm EST

report this comment



I've never eaten at Phoebe, although I've lived in Montpelier since they opened. It's just not my kind of place -- but that doesn't mean it is no good! Just not the place for me. If the regulars at Phoebe find value in the community-supported restaurant concept, then I wish the owners all the best in implementing it. Life is trying things to find out what works. The restaurant biz is a tough one. I wouldn't have the guts to try to make a go of it myself, so who would I be to criticize someone who wants to try?

I have often eaten at the Bees Knees when in Morrisville -- great food, atmosphere, and staff. The community feeling of the Bees Knees seems to lend itself to community support. Congrats to Sharon for making the expansion happen - it all looks (and tastes) great!
-- Posted by Montpelier Vermont on Sat, Feb 14, 2009, 3:28 am EST

report this comment



These two couldnt run a lemonaid stand. How about they do the community a favor and sell a product that people want to buy. In stead they come whinning for a personal bail out. What is the logic in helping a company stay in business if nobody wants the products they sell?
-- Posted by M. L. on Fri, Feb 13, 2009, 4:25 pm EST

report this comment



I'm sorry, but to compare this restaurant to the Wayside is like comparing the hope diamond to a piece of plexiglass...
-- Posted by Mel Parker on Fri, Feb 13, 2009, 4:04 pm EST

report this comment



If my memory serves me correctly, the current owners of Phoebe are the same folks who purchased the Daily Bread in Richmond, Vermont a number of years back. Subsequently, they ran the Daily Bread into the ground after only a couple years of ownership. The Daily Bread was not only an affordable, intimate place to eat, but it served the community and was a staple in Richmond for 25 years.

Once Aaron and his wife took ownership of the Daily Bread, I saw many of the same issues that are now affecting Phoebe take place. Portion sizes decreased, while the cost increased; the ingredients generally were getting worse; hours of operation were sporadic at best and they treated their employees poorly. They were forced to shut down the business and moved out of town. Ultimately, this left many Richmond residents with a sour taste in their mouths.

I would venture to say that those same business practices have landed them in a similar debacle with Restaurant Phoebe, not the financial crisis. I find it offensive that they are asking for financial support from a struggling community, when they are grossly out of touch with our needs.
-- Posted by Gogul on Fri, Feb 13, 2009, 2:50 pm EST

report this comment



Regardless of whether you like or support the restaurant, it's food, and it's prices...the strategy of selling basically a coupon book in return for discounted dinners is a good one for businesses that need upfront cash now to weather difficult times. It's not welfare, as someone suggests. If you've heard of community-supported agriculture, it's the same idea. Pay in advance for a share of the harvest. To me, if you like the business and what to see it stay in business, this is a very smart way of funding your cash flow and reconnecting with your customers. Best of luck to them!
-- Posted by EK on Fri, Feb 13, 2009, 2:09 pm EST

report this comment



Maybe Chef Gordon Ramsey could be flown in to help them out. That's if they don't mind changing they're ways, menu, so money can be made.
-- Posted by charles on Fri, Feb 13, 2009, 7:07 am EST

report this comment



This is pretty muchthe same request for "welfare" that LACE in Barre subsists on...why not have a concert for yet another overpriced, nonperforming business..?
-- Posted by patriotemt on Fri, Feb 13, 2009, 6:11 am EST

report this comment



Kudos to the owners of Phoebe for reaching out to their community and their regular customers. I always enjoy a great meal there when I travel to Vermont. The place is beautiful and the staff are always friendly and the value is great. I disagree with Tam and, seeing as they received so many responses, it seems like people like the idea a community supported business. We could use more out-of-the-box thinking in times like this. This story is inspirational!
-- Posted by J Fulmer on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 7:12 pm EST

report this comment



Doesn't a for-profit business work like this?:

You sell a product and I buy it. Why should I do more than that to support a business anywhere? Most business' go out of business. Thats the way it works. Some don't. Restaurants by nature do not have a long life expectancy. Who wants to invest in a failing business? The irrelevant "Bees Knees" example was one of expansion, not one of prolonging the misery of a dying business.
-- Posted by Tam Suleman on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 5:55 pm EST

report this comment



You get what you pay for mel. As I've always enjoyed an occasional meal at the Wayside, there is no comparison to a gourmet meal.
-- Posted by Melissa B. on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 4:44 pm EST

report this comment



I agree with AJ, went there once, to pricey and over the top. Get with it and start serving average lunches and dinners. Maybe they should talk to the folks at Wayside, the only place to eat in Central Vermont that you can still take the whole family for very few bucks! I'm tired of the NECI type menus and small portions for high $$$$'s.
-- Posted by Mel on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 3:02 pm EST

report this comment



I worked there for a week. All I'll say is what goes around comes around. Nuff said.
-- Posted by T.K. None on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 1:57 pm EST

report this comment



My family has had several wonderful experiences at Restaurant Phoebe. From warm hostess greetings to a dynamic wine list to creative, delicately-balanced and satisfying food, Phoebe is one of the best places to eat in Northern Vermont. Chef Aaron's Trout Beet Salad was so exceptional that we ordered a second portion to take with us to go! I highly disagree with some of the other posts -- the magic of Phoebe's has ben evident to all of the family and friends who have dined there with me over the years. I think their desire to connect with the community is commendable -- it's not panhandling. It's laying the foundation for a collaboration that can benefit all merchants and residents of our favoite small capital city.
-- Posted by Stacy Weinberger on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 1:30 pm EST

report this comment



Another part of the "magic" formula is to have business hours that are consistent. There were several times in the past when we attempted to have lunch there on a Friday, only to discover a hand made sign in the door announcing that the restaurant was closed for the day. After several different attempts to eat there (and always finding that sign), we simply gave up.
-- Posted by Raymond Fleming on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 12:29 pm EST

report this comment



A restaurant makes it (or not) based on what they offer the public and what they expect in return. This is the "magic" formula that these owners are ignoring.

I would love to be able to go to Phoebe( a beautiful space ) and have a lovely meal, but that is not the reality. Phoebe, on its best night, provides a marginal attempt at haute cuisine at the highest price-point around. My hard-earned dollars will tend to go elsewhere.
-- Posted by None None on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 9:18 am EST

report this comment



Phoebe's has the highest priced lunch in town but instead of repricing their menu and making it more affordable, Phoebe's owners decide to do what amounts to corporate panhandling. The logic escapes me.
-- Posted by AJ None on Thu, Feb 12, 2009, 6:16 am EST

report this comment


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Logout