TimesArgus.com - We Are Vermont

Week in review



Toolbox

Published: November 29, 2008

Our thoughts on the news of the week:



A23- year-old man who threw a pie in Gov. James Douglas' face as the governor marched in Montpelier's Independence Day Parade this summer admitted his guilt in court this week, apologized for his actions, and was sentenced. Judge Brian Grearson sentenced Matthew Manning to five days on a supervised work crew and an agreement that Manning donate $21.35 – the amount of Douglas' dry cleaning bill – to the Vermont FoodBank. It would have been wrong to treat this incident as a harmless prank with no serious consequence because Manning's stunt had long-term repercussions that include changes in how security details protect Douglas (and presumably future governors, as well) and more than likely an erosion of public access to public officials. Vermont's tradition of open government paid a price for Manning's pie-throwing stunt, and appropriately, so did Manning.



Thumbs down to:

  • East Calais General Store clerk Darci Herdling, for fabricating stories about two alleged robberies at the store – including embellishing one account by saying the robber kicked her 4-month-old baby in a car seat — that sparked an outpouring of public sympathy. In fact, Herdling was simply trying to cover up the fact that she dropped the baby. We hope Herdling's stunt (she has been charged with grand larceny) won't make the Calais community less willing to help the next person who is in genuine need.

  • The killing of Christopher Gray, a young man who was developmentally disabled but outgoing and so likeable that even his alleged killer – Timothy Smith – said in a note to Gray's family that "he was a very good guy and he didn't deserve it." Our sympathies are with Gray's family and his legal guardian over the coming holiday season.

  • The number of drivers with more than one drunk driving conviction who show up in court facing yet another. The latest was a Williamstown man who, less than 24 hours after a head-on collision that sent four to the hospital, pleaded innocent to a fourth DUI. The judicial system needs to get and keep these repeat offenders off the road for the sake of public safety. That's what jail cells are for.



    A new report by the nonpartisan Snelling Center for Government found that many Vermonters are willing to pay more in gas taxes as part of a comprehensive plan to repair failing bridges and crumbling roads, and are also willing to use more state money for transportation purposes. While not scientific, the year-long survey does set the stage for what will hopefully be a thoughtful discussion about fixing the state's deteriorating roads and bridges, and prompt quick action to get the work started by spring. Not only would bridges be safer, but more Vermonters would go back to work, giving a lift to the sagging economy. Lawmakers and Gov. James Douglas should be careful not to rule out any options at this point; every proposed funding source is worth considering. However, whatever funding solution they choose to pay for these projects must be earmarked for bridge and road repair — protected from raids for General Fund uses.



    Just how safe is our personal and financial information? Once again, the information of thousands of state employees was found to be at risk in a computer hacking incident – the latest example of the vulnerability of computerized records to theft and neglect. In the most recent case, Express Scripts Inc., which is the pharmacy benefit company for state workers, was threatened by unidentified people who demanded money in exchange for hacked personnel information. It's still unclear the full extent of the case, but the situation provides a not-so-subtle reminder to the keepers of the information to take extreme security measurers, and to all Vermonters to be cautious about disclosing personal and financial information because nothing is safe in this day and age.



    More struggling Vermonters became eligible for heating assistance this week, following congressional approval of an expansion of LIHEAP (the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program). That news couldn't come at a better time, with state officials reporting a sharp increase in the number of households applying for the heating aid. The program covers oil, kerosene and gas, and will also help with utility bills for people who heat with electricity. Times are still tough for many Vermont families, as rising unemployment statistics prove. But lower gasoline prices and little extra help with heating bills might provide some breathing room for those living on the edge.








    READER COMMENTS


    On the Manning pie-throwing issue, it's unfortunate to see the Times-Argus take a stance that both ignores the real issue concerned and places blame incorrectly.

    To be sure, Manning's actions merited a punishment, but they should not encourage an overreaction by the state, and if they do, it will be the fault of ill-considered decisions by the governor and his security personnel, not Michael Manning.

    In the larger "War on Terror", we see what a fraud and a failure such overreaction has been. Since 2001, Americans have lost considerable privacy, civil liberty, and protection as accused; meanwhile, knives and even guns still pass through airport security in embarrassing numbers now kept secret, and terrorists still kill Americans at shopping malls and public schools, if not at symbolic targets.

    The lesson to learn here is that real security consists in what we have in Vermont now: a spirit of community that holds us accountable to each other for our conduct, and maintains its core values of openness, civility, and trust through thick and thin, no matter how the rest of the US and the world shreds its laws and abandons its way of life. If we give up the law, making exceptions for harsher punishment over symbolic acts like Manning's, we all lose, and the fabric of Vermont suffers another tatter.

    Pie throwing is uncivil, and it deserves a punishment under impartial law, the same punishment, no matter who the target is. The Times-Argus, and the governor's staff, should take note of this, the real issue; that the only actions we can ever truly control are our own.
    -- Posted by Vermont Resident on Sat, Nov 29, 2008, 11:41 am EST

    report this comment


    You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

    Logout